Friday, January 22, 2016

The Fall of Coalhouse Walker

Coalhouse Walker has proven to be a very volatile character. Over the months of his courtship of Sarah, it was proven to us how persistent a man he is. He kept coming to visit the house in New Rochelle every Sunday until the day Sarah agreed to marry him. Father’s view on his stubborn pride is depicted on page 162, “It occurred to Father one day that Coalhouse Walker didn’t know he was a Negro.” This quote shows that Coalhouse, whether consciously or not, refuses to accept what the societal norm says his position in life should be. Although at first this might be interpreted as naiveness on the man’s part, perhaps being a man born a century or more too early. His stubbornness made him stand out among those too scared to stand up for their rights, like the two boys who witnessed all that transpired and could say nothing. All guises fall away when he is confronted by the Emerald Isle fireman team, where it is evident that he just refuses to accept that he can be discriminated against. He even may have recognized that he can't expect an apology on page 177, "Walker may have realized this was probably the maximum support he could expect from a policeman. At the same time he may have wondered if he'd been oversensitive to what was intended as no more than a prank." As the Coalhouse situation develops, he becomes exasperated at the complete lack of support for his plight. Lawyers turn him down, many question his reaction just like he may have questioned himself in the above quote. Many tell him to just cut his losses while he still can, which seems like reasonable advice as the stakes grow ever higher. If at first Coalhouse could have made off with a total loss of $25, the more damage is incurred to his property. First it is just slight damage to his car, but as he refuses to pay up and leave, his Model T is summarily disassembled, representing a total loss of at least $600, a massive sum by any means. The most dangerous progression of events lies in his losses. The more he sacrifices, the less he has left to care for. When Sarah dies. Coalhouse Walker loses the most important thing in his life. After spending most of his remaining holdings on his fiancĂ©e's funeral, all he has left is his beliefs. After this downwards spiral of events, I believe that in his mind, Coalhouse had no choice of actions. His pigheaded actions lost him all he held dear except his pride, so for his pride he took to solving his problems through more violent means. After diplomacy fails, all that remains is war, and Coalhouse Walker Jr., President, Provisional American Government, aims to defend his pride and fight for justice at any cost.

4 comments:

  1. I was really surprised when his pride so suddenly turned into violence. I would think that after all of the events he would let go of his pride, try a different technique, anything but what he actually ends up doing. It makes sense that Coalhouse would continue to fight for justice and his pride, but what he's doing now doesn't seem like something he would do. I don't know, it's just strange for me to see someone so put together completely lose it, so maybe you're right, maybe he didn't have a choice and just kind of..went crazy, even though he's still kind of fighting for his beliefs.

    ReplyDelete
  2. Sarah's role in all this is interesting. She mainly wants it to be over with, so they can get on with their wedding plans. But in her fatal attempt to speak with the vice president (reflecting her "innocence" about how government actually works, but also a kind of idealism--a belief in the good men at the helm who will be outraged by injustice), she does sort of mirror Coalhouse, as she petitions her government for redress of grievances.

    In Coalhouse's logic, which in a certain light is quite compelling, that government loses its legitimacy when it ceases to function as a safeguard for the justice of its citizens. If the government proves itself to be morally illegitimate, then he is justified in his "revolution" against it (in quintessentially American Revolutionary terms). And, in his view, Sarah was killed by representatives of that government as she sought redress of grievances.

    ReplyDelete
  3. When we were first introduced to Coalhouse I didn't think that he'd be capable of this. But, after everything started to go wrong for him and there didn't seem to be a lot of hope for his future (especially with Sarah dying) he freaked out and panicked. Some people don't deal well with grief and I think Coalhouse is one of those people

    ReplyDelete
  4. It is interesting how Doctorow uses violence through Coalhouse to "right the racial wrongs" in the story, and really in history. Does it show that he believes violence would have helped the integration, ante-racist movement? Or does his distance from Coalhouse literarily show that he doesn't condone that reaction? Or maybe Coalhouse's violence is okay because it is sane and calculated with a point and a grievance.

    ReplyDelete